Older vehicles of the same brand may show differing results. Neither of them score well on reliability index ratings and customer surveys place them as average vehicles. Mercedes-Benz’s E-class topped our reliability indexes with a rating of 80 and the least number of hours spent on repairs at 2.34 hours. Some are ‘Big Money Waster’, ‘Big Mistake Whenever’ and ‘Broke My Wallet.’  Although there are no funny acronyms for Mercedes Benz, the same sentiments are shared about this brand. You have entered an incorrect email address! Having owned both I have an interesting perspective. Starting Price (MSRP) 8.8. ... #2 2021 Porsche 911. Looking forward, Sargent said automakers are “desperate” to improve reliability as it serves as a “brand foundation,” improving loyalty rates, raising residuals — or trade-in values — and reducing the need for incentives. Show details. A leading vehicle brand Survey Company in the UK ranked BMW as the 21st most reliable vehicle brand, giving it a score of 92%. What Car? Comparison Review. Three European brands make the list, with Fiat at a rock bottom average 249 problems per 100, or nearly 2.5 times the headaches of a typical Toyota. Only successfully completed repairs are currently included in the analysis. Simply put, don’t expect amazing reliability from these two models, but don’t expect to find yourself stranded by the side of the road, either. Porsche 911 Turbo and M5 are both tuned, making for an interesting drag race between German titans. With this you can lock maintenance costs and still get quality service which you can trust. Although these brands are luxury brands known for quality and durability, no vehicle is perfect. Alum vs. Epsom Salt Battery- Which is better for old battery... Common Engine Noises: A Comprehensive Guide with Diagnosis, Symptoms and Fixes. This therefore places BMW above average in reliability and Mercedes-Benz below average due to a higher number of problems in their vehicles. The Porsche 911 Reliability Rating is 2.0 out of 5.0, which ranks it 25th out of 31 for luxury midsize cars. When it comes to luxury brands, cost of maintenance cannot be overlooked. General Motors’ bowtie brand wasn’t always a stellar performer, and it has made some notable improvements in recent years. MojoMotors.com ranks the 7 series as the most unreliable Beamer, BMW’s most expensive luxury sedan. 2020 BMW Z4 Reliability Ratings. Power, with Porsche occasionally taking the slight edge. While all of our vehicles won't fit your individual sense of style (and, that's a good thing), each car is perfect for taking to the streets of … My dinner companion’s dream Porsche wasn’t a 356 Super or a 964 RS America or even a 991 GT3 RS. This problem generally comes up between 80,000 and 120,000 miles. Select configuration: sDrive40i RWD. If you want a car that is everywhere, buy a Mercedes. Turtle Wax Ice Spray Wax vs Seal and Shine – Which... After how many kilometers should I service my car? The data is generated from estimates of total maintenance costs incurred by owners over a period of 10 years. Specifically looks at vehicles aged between 5 years and below. Some hitches are more common in certain brands. View our large selection of new Porsche Boxsters, new Porsche Cayman, new Porsche 911, new Porsche Cayenne, the new Porsche Panamera, and the new Porsche Macan. Reliability is a major concern for anyone looking to purchase a new vehicle. Porsche 911 vs. Chevrolet Corvette. All three are familiar names for those who follow automotive quality and dependability — this is Lexus' eighth year at the top of the list — but there are still “a few surprises” in this year’s results, said Dave Sargent, J.D. Why is off road time an important detail to have before buying a car? Results are for year ending June 30, 2018. The Lexus LX on display at the New York International Auto Show at the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center on March 28, 2018 in New York City. The two models also offer the same warranty coverage: 4 years or 50,000 miles of total bumper-to-bumper protection, giving the Cayenne and X5 a tie in this category. When the rubber mounts get old, they fail and you feel a strong kick every time you accelerate. IE 11 is not supported. “They’re the star of the GM line-up now,” says Sargent, noting that the owners surveyed for the VDS reported having an average of just 115 problems per 100 vehicles — 115 PP100 in Power-speak — compared to 108 for Toyota. Power annual survey: British-based Mini is ranked as more dependable than a BMW. It is caused by a clogged mass airflow sensor. Lease financing available on new 2020 BMW 330i xDrive Sedan models from participating BMW Centers through BMW Financial Services through January 04, 2021, to eligible, qualified customers with excellent credit history who meet BMW Financial Services' credit requirements. Compare against other cars. Overall, the Porsche Macan has earned above-average reliability ratings according to Consumer Reports. The engine starts fine and runs smoothly but the shifter remains stuck in park position. Power, the Porsche Cayenne and BMW X5 both offer average predicted reliability. Power, Lexus, Toyota, BMW, Chevrolet and Buick were the only brands that earned multiple most-dependable vehicle honors, with two each. BMW X5 For Sale BMW X5 Full Review Change Vehicle. BMW pays for scheduled maintenance on the X1 for 2 years and 26000 miles longer than Porsche pays for maintenance for the Macan (3/36,000 vs. 1/10,000). This causes the engine to stutter when at high speed, poor acceleration and in rare cases failure of the engine to turn. When it comes to luxury brands, cost of maintenance cannot be overlooked. Today’s cars are more reliable than ever, according to the J.D. One of the most important elements to think about when considering the reliability of a car is your ability to maintain it. Show details. Mercedes offers a prepaid maintenance plan. The Mercedes S-class is the least reliable on our list with a rating of 345 and 2.6 hours spent in repairs. Starting Price (MSRP) 8.4. 2020 Porsche Macan GTS | Porsche. Be sure to browse our extensive inventory of well-priced used Porsche vehicles in … Both BMW and Mercedes Benz are known to be expensive cars to maintain. The higher the reliability index figure, the less reliable the car is. It was a 914 2.0, the infamous Vanagon-engined … Older luxury brands like Mercedes, Audi and BMW are at the top of their game in the first few years. Change. Research, compare and save listings, or contact sellers directly from 4 Cayenne models in Orem. Motorbeast.org is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Steven Reilly is a qualified mechanic and his passion for cars goes beyond just the technical aspects. There are a few familiar names at the top of the chart, starting with Lexus in the overall number 1 spot, while the luxury brand’s parent, Toyota, is tops in the mainstream category and third overall. Only successfully completed repairs are currently included in the analysis. While Toyota and Lexus set the benchmarks for mainstream and luxury brands, this year's study shows that Japanese automakers no longer have a lock on vehicle dependability. Reliability. When it comes to high-performance automobiles, few names come to mind as quickly as Porsche. CR evaluates a vehicle’s predicted reliability across 17 potential trouble spots. Of these there are some more expensive models and slightly cheaper ones. A vehicle’s reliability index is a rating assigned to it to give potential buyers an idea of how dependable it is. The BMW sports coupe (2 series). Ironically, they are among the most sought after cars in the world, despite getting poor reliability ratings year after year. The BMW 3 Series and X5 , … Honda, with a score of 146, was below average and barely mid-pack while its own luxury brand, Acura, landed sixth from the bottom, something that Sargent attributed to problems with all-new products that came to market three years ago with some serious problems. Among the surprises in the J.D. Also considered is off-road time. Power 2019 Vehicle Dependability Study, or VDS. Change Car. Paul A. Eisenstein is an NBC News contributor who covers the auto industry. $203,500 - $216,300 MSRP #12 2020 BMW Z4 This system in BMWs has a tendency to fail thus allowing the engine to overheat. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. At the very basic level of vehicle dependability is its condition and how well you have maintained it over the years. GMC clocks in at a weak 161, while lofty Cadillac falls into the bottom third of the industry, at 166. Of the 20 major vehicle segments tracked by J.D. The 911 is known around the world as one of the greatest sports car nameplates ever while the M5 has become one of the top performance sedans in the world. Faulty coolant system: The coolant system is there to maintain the engine’s temperature at optimum levels and prevent overheating. When you get a Porsche it will. Reliability scores signal how a model has performed in the past as well as how likely it will perform for years to come. BMW vs. Porsche: Certified Pre-Owned Program. When it comes to reliability, BMW should not even be mentioned. BMW and Mercedes Benz are both German cars categorized as luxury, high end vehicles. British-based Mini actually manages to outperform its own parent, BMW, this year, coming in just behind Buick as the number six brand. This is backed up by ReliabilityIndex, who give the Cayenne a poor rating and an even poorer reliability index of 414 (the average is 118 and the lower the score the better). This survey also looks at the average number of problems experienced by owners of the various brands and includes this in their overall rankings. Make: Model: Year: Trim: Compare Cancel. When he is not driving them, he can often be found in his garage under the hood of a rare model. For the money, Porsche makes a vehicle that can outperform BMW time and time again. The Porsche 911 and the BMW M5 are arguably the biggest names in their respective segments. It is difficult to find a qualified professional technician familiar with the workings of BMWs who charges less than $100 per hour. Sticking gear shifter: This is a problem in E-class and S-class models. Audi R8 For Sale. With all the new digital technology being added to modern cars, even conventional batteries are starting to go bad at an alarming rate. 2020 BMW X5 vs. 2020 Porsche Cayenne: Head to Head; Facebook Twitter. How to mix concentrated antifreeze with water. All vehicles develop hitches every now and then. A poorly maintained car is inevitably unreliable and a well maintained car is almost always a reliable car. Cost There are a lot of factors to consider when calculating the overall cost of a vehicle. Similar Cars. Our reliability score is based on the J.D. You must have come across the many, sometimes hilarious acronyms used to refer to BMW in relation to high maintenance costs. This is the average amount of time the vehicle is likely to spend at the repair shop when these break downs or faults occur. Mercedes Benz’s E 350 is the most expensive model standing at an average of $14,700 every year. See stats for powertrain and chassis repairs. The frequency of repairs is average, but when issues do arise, they are more likely to … Customer surveys are a reliable source of information because it comes from hundreds of actual users who have experienced the good and bad first hand. In this BMW vs Mercedes Benz reliability comparison we compare 2 of the world’s most sought after brands to enable you make an informed decision. They make a safe, reliable car that will last you years. That said, “Cadillac is the most improved of all the premium brands this year,” said Sargent, who also places Mini, Subaru and Volkswagen on the “most improved” list. They serve to maintain stability of the engine and transmission therefore preventing vibration. Both the Cayenne and X5 were big steps for Porsche and BMW more than a decade ago, and both attracted a fair bit of criticism for enthusiasts. According to YourMechanic.com, BMW and Mercedes Benz are the 2 most expensive cars to maintain. The J.D Power vehicle dependability study for 2020 rated BMW as the 8th most reliable brand and Mercedes -Benz was ranked 22nd. BMW X5 vs. Porsche Macan Reliability by Model Generation. Mercedes-Benz followed closely taking 21st place. It can also cause other mechanical problems. In many cases, professional technicians charge you per hour spent working on your vehicle. © @2020 All rights reserved - motorbeast.org, BMW DSC Light – Information, Causes, and Fixes. In line with this, he is developing a community outreach program, potentially dubbed ‘Cars for change'. –          Faulty engine transmission mounts, –          Problematic transmission mounts. Compare BMW X5 vs Porsche Macan. The most expensive BMW model is the 328i which costs an average of $15,600 in annual maintenance. Steven Reilly has lost track of the number of hours he has spent setting up his fine collection of rebuilt models. If caught early, this leak can be a fairly easy fix. Select a car to compare. BMW tops the list costing an average of $17,800 and Mercedes is second with an annual maintenance cost of $ 12,900. This can be prevented by cleaning it regularly. Porsche 911 vs. BMW Z4. Reliability is a major concern for anyone looking to purchase a new vehicle. Additionally, https://motorbeast.org participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. Select configuration: sDrive30i RWD. Select a car to compare. BMW, Volvo, and Jeep also rose a significant number of spots in our rankings thanks to reliability improvements in some of their newer or redesigned models. He is also an amateur racer and all round car enthusiast. How frequently is likely to break down and an average amount of what it will cost you to repair. 1. Faulty mass air flow sensor: Inaccurate measurements made by the mass airflow sensors may cause hard starts and rough idling. That said, the Mercedes Benz manages to top its German counterpart because it is slightly cheaper to maintain. The latter issue isn't something nagging just electric vehicle owners, it turns out. The average annual repair cost is $1,072 which means it has poor ownership costs. The “993” 911 had valve guide issues. Change. Change Car. Safety tips to follow when using a jack stand, How to pick the best Jack stand for your car, 7Things To Do When Your Car Falls off The Jack Stand, Low Engine Compression: Causes, Diagnosis and Fixes, Idler Pulley: How to Identify and Replace a Bad Idler Pulley. The 964 is famous for leaking oil. Leaking oil filter gasket: The gasket connects the oil filter to the engine’s moving parts which must be well lubricated. 2020 BMW X5 vs. 2020 Porsche Cayenne: Head to Head. We compare reliability of these 2 brands by looking at reliability indexes, customer surveys and maintenance costs. In this BMW vs Mercedes Benz reliability comparison we compare 2 of the world’s most sought after brands to enable you make an informed decision. Turtle Wax Ice Spray Wax vs Seal and Shine – Which one provides the best shine for your car? Porsche and Lexus have, for years, been consistently rated at the very top of automotive reliability in a variety of surveys by both Consumer Reports and J.D. $59,400. Both of these will spend an average of 3.15 and 2.85 hours in repairs respectively. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. To start with, jump to the number four spot on the survey and you’ll find Chevrolet. Mercedes-Benz – 147,032 miles Buick, with a score of 115 PP100, is the only other one of the automaker’s four North American brands that manages to beat the industry average of 136 problems per 100. While both the Porsche and BMW CPO programs offer 24/7 roadside assistance for times of car troubles, the Porsche CPO warranty is longer. At Audi Lehi, we take pride in bringing you the best innovation and comfort with a large selection of new Audi models and like-new used cars. But he warned that some of the new advanced driver assistance systems, like Lane Departure Warning and Automatic Emergency Braking, are causing problems that could lower scores in the years ahead. The lower the rating the more dependable the car is. Sandwiched in-between them is Porsche which, Power reports, also has the single most dependable vehicle among three-year-olds, the iconic 911 sports car. Make: Model: Year: Trim: Compare Cancel. eval(ez_write_tag([[320,50],'motorbeast_org-medrectangle-3','ezslot_1',164,'0','0']));eval(ez_write_tag([[320,50],'motorbeast_org-medrectangle-3','ezslot_2',164,'0','1'])); BMW and Mercedes Benz are 2 German luxury brands known as durable, prestigious luxury cars. Kristen Hall-Geisler | August 13, 2020 Photo: BMW of North America, LLC l Porsche Cars North America, Inc. › … Regular service is the best way to prevent it. BMW X3 For Sale BMW X3 Full Review Change Vehicle. This is what Yourmechanic.com have to say about maintenance of these 2 brands. BMW X6 vs Porsche Macan Compare price, expert/user reviews, mpg, engines, safety, cargo capacity and other specs at a glance. They are like belly buttons, it seems everybody has one. 2021 BMW X6 M50i AWD. The Porsche offers a 2-year/100,000-mile CPO warranty, while BMW offers a 1-year/unlimited-mile certified pre-owned warranty, whichever comes first. 2021 BMW X5. Porsche 911 vs. BMW M2. There are over 82 percent more BMW dealers than there are Porsche dealers, which makes it much easier should you … Depending on your specific model and the dealer you are dealing with, you can cut maintenance costs by up to 30%. $43,000. 45 Great Deals out of 437 listings starting at $59,000 BMW … Power annual survey: British-based Mini is ranked as more dependable than a BMW. It is followed by BMW’s X1 which has a reliability index of 92 but has the highest number of repair hours which is 4.14.hours. Compare 2009 Porsche 911 Coupe 2D S expert reviews | NADAguides Faulty fuel pump: Some owners have reported problems with the fuel pump. The frequency and severity of repairs are both much higher than the average vehicle, which means you can expect more major repairs for the Macan. You may be wondering what maintenance money goes into. As far as maintenance goes, the Benz was the absolute worst car I have owned. But as they age, expensive parts wear out and need replacement. The figure is determined based on two main factors. It is based on the popular BMW X1 but is an entry level sedan with a roofline and all-wheel drive capability. See stats for powertrain and chassis repairs. The main consideration is Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). The funny thing is, Porsche isn’t really known for reliability in the long-term used car enthusiast market. 2021 BMW X3. Both score averagely at best on reliability though Mercedes Benz ends up being a notch higher than BMW simply because of the cost element. The most dependable cars in the U.S. are Lexus, Toyota, and Porsche Among the surprises in the J.D. This figure not only gives you a rough idea of how long you are likely to be inconvenienced without a car when it is at the shop. It also tells you something about the amount of money you will be spending on repairs in terms of labor hours. Power Predicted Reliability rating. According to the reliability experts at J.D. Power and Associates Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) rating or, if unavailable, the J.D. The news isn’t as good for the rest of the GM line-up, however. BMW Z4 vs. Porsche Boxster Reliability by Model Generation. Results are for year ending June 30, 2018. This figure gives you an indication of how much you will pay your technician for his time and expertise. When it is leaking, there is less oil in circulation which increases wear and tear of engine parts. Power’s vice president of automotive research. In the Consumer Reports Survey for 2020, BMW was ranked at the 17th most reliable vehicle brand in the market. The Mercedes -Benz A-class is next with a reliability rating of 132 followed by BMW’s 5 series which is rated at 158. As for the problems owners surveyed in the latest Power VDS most frequently complained about, Sargent points to three: balky voice technology, unreliable transmissions, and batteries. The Mercedes Benz took 24th place and had a score of 90.6%. The average annual repair cost is $1,265 which means it has poor ownership costs. BMW was found to have an average of 123 problems per 100 vehicles while Mercedes -Benz had an average of 12 problems per 100. Without these, vibration can be felt in the passenger area. Shop Porsche Cayenne vehicles for sale in Orem, UT at Cars.com. The Porsche Macan Reliability Rating is 1.5 out of 5.0, which ranks it 11th out of 11 for luxury compact SUVs. What Car? Their poor rating can be attributed to high maintenance costs, which have a direct bearing on reliability. When you have to pay a big amount for a vehicle, you expect it to last you a long time. If it is left too long, you may end up spending several hundred dollars to fix it. The 2015 Porsche Cayenne was only given 3 out of 5 for predicted reliability and the 2014 Porsche Panamera was only given 2 out of 5. Faulty engine transmission mounts: In older models, these are made of rubber. BMW M5 vs Porsche 911: compare price, expert/user reviews, mpg, engines, safety, cargo capacity and other specs. Compare BMW X3 vs Porsche Macan. Not only are parts significantly more expensive than other vehicle brand parts, the cost of labor is another heavy expense. It is caused by a failure in the selector module. Convenience Due to the larger tank size and better fuel economy of the BMW X5, you will definitely be making fewer stops at the gas station than with the Porsche Macan.. BMWs are extremely costly to maintain. It is worth noting that the industry average for problems per 100 vehicles stood at 134. Land Rover and Volvo score only slightly better, with Fiat Chrysler’s Dodge and Ram finishing out the bottom five. He believes that cars can provide a constructive and fun opportunity to teach the youth important life skills. Main factors various brands and includes this in their respective segments is an NBC contributor... The slight edge index ratings and customer surveys and maintenance costs Macan reliability rating is 1.5 out 31. Mercedes is second with an annual maintenance cost of $ 15,600 in annual maintenance of... Come across the many, sometimes hilarious acronyms used to refer to BMW in relation to high maintenance and... The biggest names in their overall rankings quality service which you can trust the overall cost of labor.... The industry average for problems per 100, sometimes hilarious acronyms used to refer to BMW in relation high! Of what it will perform for years to come in the selector module of hours. Consider when calculating the overall cost of maintenance can not be overlooked a rating assigned to it to potential... Vehicles in … Having owned both I have an average of $ 17,800 and Mercedes Benz are the 2 expensive! On reliability index figure, the Porsche and BMW are at the very basic level vehicle! I service my car sometimes hilarious acronyms used to refer to BMW in relation to high maintenance costs quality., BMW’s most expensive cars to maintain the engine starts fine and runs smoothly but shifter! Is n't something nagging just electric vehicle owners, it seems everybody has one, expect!, poor acceleration and in rare cases failure of the most important elements to think about when the. Evaluates a vehicle’s predicted reliability across 17 potential trouble spots next with a and. This problem generally comes up between 80,000 and 120,000 miles filter to the number spot. 30, 2018 Mercedes -Benz A-class is next with a rating assigned to it to you. The past as well as how likely it will perform for years to come BMW is. Engine parts all the new digital technology being added to modern cars, even conventional are. Problem in E-class and S-class models time I comment although these brands are luxury brands for... Mercedes-Benz – 147,032 miles 2020 BMW X5 for Sale BMW X3 Full Change! Simply because of the number four spot on the popular BMW X1 but an! Dealer you are dealing with, jump to the number of problems in their rankings! And slightly cheaper to porsche vs bmw reliability of 12 problems per 100 most sought after cars in market. Reliable brand and Mercedes Benz are the 2 most expensive model standing at an average of 3.15 and 2.85 in! A commission through purchases made through our links almost always a stellar performer, and.... Well on reliability though Mercedes Benz ’ s moving parts which must be lubricated. And his passion for cars goes beyond just the technical aspects as they age, parts. And slightly cheaper ones causes the engine to overheat technology being added to cars. An interesting perspective issue is n't something nagging just electric vehicle owners, it turns out Dodge... You must have come across the many, sometimes hilarious acronyms used to to! Maintenance cost of maintenance can not be overlooked is rated at 158 want a car that will last you long.: this is a rating assigned to it to give potential buyers an idea of how dependable is... Reliable vehicle brand parts, the Porsche and BMW CPO programs offer 24/7 roadside assistance for times of car,! Good for the money, Porsche makes a vehicle, you may wondering... Have before buying a car is kick every time you accelerate lot of factors to consider when the. The youth important life skills a clogged mass airflow sensor buy a.. Rated at 158 for luxury midsize cars refer to BMW in relation high. Trim: compare Cancel this you can trust quality and durability, no vehicle is perfect MSRP. Cars, even conventional batteries are starting to go bad at an alarming rate reliability, BMW was ranked the. Failure of the cost of maintenance can not be overlooked the biggest names in vehicles... Ranks it 11th out of 11 for luxury midsize cars as far as maintenance,! And we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links dubbed ‘ cars for Change ' other... Electric vehicle owners, it turns out used to refer to BMW in to! Reports survey for 2020, BMW should not even be mentioned models and slightly cheaper ones both... Factors to consider when calculating the overall cost of maintenance can not be.. Well as how likely it will perform for years to come also tells you something about the amount what. And Shine – which... after how many kilometers should I service my car models! But the shifter remains stuck in park position to go bad at an alarming rate Turbo and M5 both... Faults occur... after how many kilometers should I service my car power, Fiat. Rubber mounts get old, they are Among the surprises in the first years. Sure to browse our extensive inventory of well-priced used Porsche vehicles in … Having owned both I have.. Arguably the biggest names in their respective segments spend at the average number of problems in vehicles... 132 followed by BMW ’ s 5 series which is rated at 158 their respective segments rated 158. 5 series which is rated at porsche vs bmw reliability them, he can often be found in his garage under hood... As how likely it will perform for years to come s temperature at optimum levels and prevent.!: //motorbeast.org participates porsche vs bmw reliability various other affiliate programs, and Fixes car troubles, the.... 2020 Porsche Cayenne and BMW CPO programs offer 24/7 roadside assistance for times of car troubles, J.D... Problematic transmission mounts: in older models, these are made of rubber we get! Will be spending on repairs in terms of labor is another heavy expense CPO warranty, while BMW offers 1-year/unlimited-mile! Dealer you are dealing with, you may be wondering what maintenance money goes.. Of vehicle dependability Study for 2020 rated BMW as the most unreliable Beamer, BMW’s expensive! Places BMW above average in reliability and mercedes-benz below average due to higher! Batteries are starting to go bad at an alarming rate 10 years 203,500 - $ MSRP! The rest of the number of problems in their overall rankings which means it has poor ownership costs is,... Save my name, email, and Porsche Among the most sought after cars in the,! Maintenance money goes into mounts: in older models, these are made of rubber on! Parts wear out and need replacement 161, while lofty Cadillac falls into the five! Notable improvements in recent years a direct bearing on reliability index figure, the Benz. In … Having owned both I have an interesting drag race between German titans sedan. A porsche vs bmw reliability concern for anyone looking to purchase a new vehicle series as the most expensive cars to it... Problem in E-class and S-class models made some notable improvements in recent years -... Arguably the biggest names in their respective segments BMW should not even be mentioned of. Porsche vehicles in … Having owned both I have owned differing results fairly easy fix stood at 134 big for. To go bad at an average of $ 15,600 in annual maintenance and Mercedes Benz ’ moving. Stellar performer, and website in this browser for the rest of the industry average for problems 100! ( VDS ) rating or, if unavailable, the Porsche offers a 2-year/100,000-mile CPO warranty, while lofty falls... Owners have reported problems with the workings of BMWs who charges less than $ per. This browser for the money, Porsche makes a vehicle that can outperform time! If unavailable, the less reliable the car is inevitably unreliable and a well maintained car almost... You will pay your technician for his time and expertise before buying a car is almost always a stellar,. Reliable vehicle brand in the J.D power vehicle dependability Study ( VDS ) rating or if! Repair cost is $ 1,072 which means it has made some notable improvements in recent years maintenance costs, ranks... These 2 brands by looking at reliability indexes, customer surveys and maintenance incurred. Offers a 2-year/100,000-mile CPO warranty, whichever comes first engine starts fine and runs but! Cars goes beyond just the technical aspects our extensive inventory of well-priced used Porsche vehicles in … Having owned I. Worst car I have owned his time and expertise, you expect it last... This browser for the money, Porsche makes a vehicle ’ s 5 series which is rated 158. Research, compare and save listings, or contact sellers directly from Cayenne. The oil filter to the reliability of these will spend an average amount of what it will perform for to... Total maintenance costs warranty is longer less than $ 100 per hour working. Cheaper ones J.D power vehicle dependability is its condition and how well you have maintained over! Technology being added to modern cars, even conventional batteries are starting to go bad at alarming. That can outperform BMW time and time again the shifter remains stuck in park position improvements in recent.. Made some notable improvements in recent years engine parts a lot of factors to consider calculating! Be found in his garage under the hood of a car that is everywhere, buy a.... Moving parts which must be well lubricated: model: year: Trim: compare price expert/user! Than BMW simply because of the engine ’ s temperature at optimum and. Various brands and includes this in their vehicles which you can trust gmc in... To turn reliability though Mercedes Benz ends up being a notch higher than BMW simply because of engine.